Marketing the Right Products – David Twiggs

SLR_3620_JPG

I was speaking recently at the American Association of Retirement Communities national conference in Memphis about “Repositioning the Large Scale Community to be Relevant in Today’s Market” and was asked about effective marketing campaigns. Once you understand your market and have positioned your community to authentically serve relevant lifestyle options, there are some excellent media resources out there for marketing your community.    Ideal Living magazine as a great national example and Center for Carolina Living is a regional platform. However, I quickly turned our discussion to the much-overlooked fact that these media outlets can only convey the story you supply. Marketing can never make up for a product problem and many of our communities have a product problem.

 

If we continue to advertise a 25-year-old story, we will not be attractive to the coming markets. If we cannot actually deliver authentic and fulfilling lifestyle options relevant to today’s market, we will simply fall into irrelevance. The things that drew the people who moved to your community in the past do not motivate today’s market. Not only are we experiencing the change from silent generation to boomers, we are dealing with post recession value shifts and fragmented media.

 

Fixing a product problem is about finding the unique lifestyle options you can provide and creating those opportunities. I work in rural destination and resort style communities so I look at what markets I can develop in addition to the country club sports model that the original developer banked on. Notice, I said lifestyles in addition to, not replacing what we have. Nothing wrong with an element of the country club model but it better not be the only product you offer. The golf centric community market is saturated on all levels and price points but it can still be a strong part of your holistic lifestyle options. If a program you offer is no longer relevant, it will die a natural death. Who is building a new shuffleboard stadium? No one, they are  irrelevant. You had better have lifestyle options relevant to the coming market to attract new growth. We should protect the elements of our lifestyle we love and add complimentary lifestyle options that we can authentically provide. Be Unique. Generic and boring are well represented in the market. You are not trying to attract everyone only those who want your unique lifestyle.

 

For Hot Springs Village, I have developed a Master Plan Workbook in which we explore possible new lifestyle possibilities, housing typology, engagement brands and community branding. Notice this is titled a workbook not an engraved in stone plan. This is an ever changing document. We explore many ideas for lifestyle and community improvements. We don’t implement them all. Some fit some do not, but we are not afraid to explore all options and are daily improving our formally dated products. If you have a unique product, marketing is much easier. Getting picked out of a mass of similar communities is difficult and often leads to wasting our limited marketing dollars.

 

You are welcome to look at the current version of my Master Plan Work Book for HSV. Please remember it is an ongoing presentation piece so some details and all proprietary information such as market studies for housing, hotel, commercial and retail have been omitted. Each community is unique. You can’t simply copy someone else’s model. Look at your products, understand your market, and make sure your story is relevant before you invest your marketing dollars.

CLICK HERE FOR A PDF Masterplan Workbook 1221.2014 UPDATE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tjFZlnYuFQ

Adding Value is a Long Term Game – David Twiggs

 

I wanted to share the great news from Savannah Lakes Village in McCormick SC and talk a bit about pace.  Adding value to create authenticity and the ability to reposition a community does not happen overnight.   The technology project that allowed SLV to become ” High Tech, High Nature,”  a tag line Kirk Smith created back in 2010 when marketing director for SLV,  was developed over many years. Kirk caught on to this concept early and knew the value it would create.  During those years, Kirk and I continued to create other value added products such as the Savannah Lakes Rod and Gun Club,  the Outdoor Adventure Club, and the context brand of the Little River Blueway Outdoor Adventure Region.  We looked at alternative housing typology with smaller footprints and denser design.  In other words, we focused on creating the conditions for future investment.  We did this daily.  The work and value is cumulative.  From planning individual road signs to creating regional partnerships, it is all part of creating authentic value that will attract quality investment.  To the layman, an announcement comes out in a paper such as one below and the thought is how fortunate for them.  In reality it is the result of many years of hard work adding value.  Create the conditions and the investment will come.  Congratulations to Kirk and the SLV Team for having the drive and focus take the value to the marketplace.  Thanks to Bob Stockton for the article below.

 

Rod___Gun_Club_-_Savannah_Lakes_Village

New Developers Enter into Contract to Purchase
Resort Peninsula & Undeveloped Village Acreage

Savannah Lakes Village announced last week one of the most significant McCormick County economic development projects since the creation of the Village itself in the late 1980s.

Better Homes and Gardens’ (BH&G) CEO Tommy Stephenson, Joe Todd, BH&G director of new homes development, and their development team have entered into a comprehensive contract to acquire the existing Savannah Lakes Resort lodge, conference center, two townhomes, the lakefront restaurant, and other undeveloped land along Highway 378 and Holiday Road. The deal would also provide access for BH&G to acquire existing homesites located in Savannah Lakes Village to fuel new housing development programs.

“This investment and redevelopment will ignite visitation and home building programs here,” said Village Chief Operating Officer Kirk Smith. “The resort peninsula is a first impression to visitors coming into South Carolina from Georgia, and we are pleased with the potential of Better Homes & Gardens’ acquisition and reinvestment in these important amenities.

“The broad objective is to re-invest in the resort peninsula, lodge, conference center and restaurant to make it a welcoming entrance to the Village and the County of McCormick,” Smith said.

The strategic acquisitions of these assets are part of a larger development initiative to enhance the Village’s discovery and visitation programs and support both residential and commercial growth.

“We are bringing stability to the table,” said Todd. “All the amenities needed for a great community are in place here, but the most important Village asset is the people. We want to help Village residents to grow this community the way they want to see it grow.”

“Beyond the near-term purchase of the assets is a longer-term objective to create various residential and commercial assets for the Village to realize its full potential,” Smith said. “The first phase of the development project for just the resort peninsula, as envisioned by the developers, will represent a multi-million dollar investment.

“Our development partners share in our values of doing this right, while building a good relationship with Village and county residents. They are in it for more than economic benefit. The actions of all parties are to build confidence and trust,” he said.

Increasing evidence of the relationship is visible in new homes under construction: a Discovery Home on Martin Drive expected to be completed in late January; four new models, and three new spec homes under construction. BH&G has begun Village advertising in Augusta media and will announce major kick-off events — ribbon cuttings and open houses — when warmer spring temperatures occur.

Courtesy of the McCormick Messenger, Story by Bob Stockton (Parts Omitted)

 

Conscious Development: Creating Places Where People Thrive

IMG_0020

Density and Intensity of Eureka Springs, AR

David Twiggs

When is development good?  Many projects and developers took a bad rap over the past few years as projects slowed or were abandoned in the wake of the real estate bubble bust.  I have found this a very interesting time as we have been able to really see the wheat separated from the chaff.  Real value became evident from the sales prices. Some communities held and even grew in value while other stagnated and declined. We can read endless statistics on trends in housing types, square footages, amenities and governance structures.  We can study the different margins offered by new construction techniques. Even after sorting through these, I can find clear examples of  communities that remain great places and seem to defy much of the statistical logic.  Exceptions to the rules so to speak, with varying degrees of buildout, widely different amenity focus and different community personalities.

After looking at hundreds of communities from the most successful to the worst failures, I believe that the communities that have sustainable success are those disciplined enough to keep a conscious focus on creating relevant value during initial planning and as the community matures throughout the years.  Often when we think of value in real estate, perceived value is top of mind.  This seems to stem from a bias to the sales point of view.  A marketers creation of urgency and desire to purchase a specific property is creation of  perceived value in the mind of the potential owner. Property must sell for developers to get return on investment and everyone to paid. Nothing wrong with getting paid for working hard.  I wouldn’t use a marketer who did not know how to create perceived value.  In common usage the term perceived value is used generically to say how a resident feels about their property.  However, as creators of communities, we need to sharpen our vocabulary and be specific in what is created and evolved over time.

Truly successful communities have a different vibe going on. The success of great places comes from the sustained satisfaction of the dynamic population overtime. I call this Relevant Value because it evolves to prove or disprove the perceived value at the point of sale. As our products are typically the most expensive purchase our customer will ever make, we have the responsibility to assure that our marketing promises will not only be kept, but actually create inherently satisfying place to continue to evolve where individuals can thrive.

I believe life is happiness based.  Perceived value can be true or false for a potential owner, was it based in reality or just hype.  A property purchase is typically as aspirational as it is functional. Even more so in second home or retirement based real estate purchases.   Perceived value creates sales.  Some promises even when kept turn out to be hollow. The are not inherently satisfying.  Relevant value creates happy people over time.  It does not matter if our development is for  starter homes, a major tourism destination, or a mix of lifestyles and stages; being conscious of creating places that meet the higher happiness needs of the subcultures we attract is our responsibility.  We must focus on the nature of the different subcultures we want to attract and be sure they are complimentary.  We must be specific not generic.  One community model will satisfy everyone.  Yet for years, the second home and retirement market has basically supplied a single model and cast questioning glances at anyone wanting something different. We must make the right promises and keep them.

Recently, I was having a conversation with Todd Zimmerman of Zimmerman/Volk Associates who is doing a market study for a project I am putting together. After discussing the holistic approach I was planning for this project, Todd gave me the language to describe the elements I was trying to influence, a new framework for the terms of  “density and intensity.”  While Todd was much more eloquent and nuanced in his explanation, I simplified it to fit my need.   Density is how the built environment engages people. Intensity is how the mix of cultures engages people  To create relevant value, we must be conscious to address both to these elements. Exactly how we do this varies with the nature of the place we seek to create and the subcultures we seek to serve.  The quality of place we create impacts the happiness and wellbeing of those we seek to attract. That is a fundamental  responsibility of Conscious Development.

Where Have the Real Estate Investors Gone? David Twiggs, AICP

Placemaking Planning: Grove Park Market Drawing by Dr. Yang Luo, Director of Placemaking Hot Springs Village, AR

Placemaking Planning: Grove Park Market
Drawing by Dr. Yang Luo, Director of Placemaking Hot Springs Village, AR

I was recently in two meetings that seemed to be lamenting the same condition. All of the real estate investors have disappeared. The consensus seemed to be, the recession killed the real estate investor. One of these meetings was a discussion by several community professionals trying to revitalize their respective master planned communities. The other was a grassroots organization to revitalize a historic but challenged section of a tourism driven city. This got me thinking about the role of private investment in existing community development and redevelopment.

In my present project, I find that the investor has not disappeared at all. The unsophisticated real estate investor is gone. The easy money for any project is gone.

The amateur buying twenty overpriced lots in pre-sale based on a rendering of what might be built is not a reliable entity as it was in the past. We must now supply sound business plans with specific value enhancing strategies; in other words, we must work hard to have projects worth investing in. The recession has killed the lazy uninformed investor that perpetuated mediocre projects. And that’s a good thing.

So how do we find investors in revitalizing our communities? The recession has brought on so many opportunities for assembling property that had previously been sold. Property may have been abandoned and fell into the ownership of an association. It may have reverted back to a town, county, or state for failure to pay the taxes. There is also the shadow inventory of people who pay taxes and assessments but would gladly rid themselves of an unimproved property if there were a market or an entity that would take it. My point, there is now property available at a low cost basis that was not available pre-recession. What are our plans for that property?

Today’s investor wants to see a clear plan for a property to become marketable and relevant to the present and coming marketplace. There needs to be specific strategies for adding value to specific property. Personal real estate is the ultimate lifestyle product. It fundamentally must have real community and ultra-local value. Community value is the lifestyle improvements you receive by living first in the chosen region and then the specific community. There must be true quality of place. There must be relevant lifestyle options.

Ultra-local value opportunities come from fulfilling the original lifestyle promises for all the properties inside a community. Many developers in the past 30 years focused on the premium lot sales. Waterfront, golf courses, view and open space lots were the cash cows and the remaining interior lots were simply not considered as to the livability. This worked in the sales process because the lifestyle of the premium lots was being promised to all; but  it was  never delivered to all in a livable fashion. The buyer of an interior lot finds that they do not have the access and lifestyle of the lake house across the street. They must get in their car and drive to access the lake or any other lifestyle amenity for that matter. It has no ultra-local value. I define ultra-local value as what I can leave my home and do without getting in an automobile. Can I walk the dog down to the lake, can I access a trail system, walk to the art studio, or bike over to a social area, have coffee and people watch? This is ultra-local value.

Value can be a point source. There is not much value to “your neighbor has great lakefront but you can drive to the access just 3 miles away,” or “you can’t see it or access it from here but there is a great open space just over there that you can drive to.” Property was sold as if the prime amenity had ultra-local value rather than simply community value. Look at where your homes developed. What was the source of that value? How much “gravity” does that point of value have? In other words how large a radius of lots does that value impact. A single private home with a great view radiates no gravity to the neighboring lot with no view. A coffee shop that is walkable from 300 homes radiates a lot of ultra-local value while still supplying community value. While we do want to have premium properties available, the premium price garnered by the view, lake or open space lot could be leveraged much better by allowing common access to that point source value gravity in the form of a neighborhood gathering area. This allows the property value and marketability to be raised over all property in a radius rather than at a single point.

The amount of value gravity will always vary by location within the community. From a technical point of view, the investor is looking for investment areas where the existing socio/spacial value gravity can be influenced. Specific improvements are wanted. Defined, understandable, and doable. In more general terms, we must get to work planning our futures. If we have feasible strategies to improve the livability and relevance of specific areas and market those correctly; the savvy investor will find you.

 

 

Community Builder or Consumer – David Twiggs

Image

To build an extraordinary destination community, we must realize our residents and visitors want to belong to a community rather than simply be a consumer.  We must create the seeds for citizenship.  We are often faced with a culture of community consumers not a group of contributing citizen community builders.

I spent 18 years living and working in the North Carolina High Country in the Blowing Rock, Beech Mountain and Linville triangle.  In this area, there was a proliferation of communities being built to meet the in migration, second home and rental housing demand.  Many of these were very well done creating a community personality that added to the cultural richness of the community.  While these were clearly defined areas they were relatively porous allowing exchange of communication, ideas, and commonality.   These communities were generally considered to be good engaged neighbors.

Other communities developed into isolationist monocultures that were generally considered unwelcome even after many years of existence.  These fostered the” Us vs. Them” mentality.  While they were successful real estate development projects in that they sold through and made the developer a lot of money.  They were not necessarily successful in adding to the long-term health of the larger community.

Consumers are like investors in a stock.  As long as the community is thriving, they receive their dividends in the form of quantity of amenity per dollar paid in taxes, dues, or fees and in increased property values when they decide to sell their investment.  Just like in stocks, owners change on a daily basis. If their dividends are not what they expect, they sell the investment. Since a community’s major dividend has been the lifestyle and perceived quality of life, the same dividend may leave one investor unimpressed while going beyond another’s expectations. A community cannot be all things to all people. It must enhance its unique qualities and values and seek those to whom the lifestyle resonates.  The one constant is that the people will eventually change.  With this come two schools of thought.

The American zeitgeist on what is considered of value is now shifting towards a citizenship point if view.  In response, we had better set up policies, governance and traditions that foster the unique authentic value in our community.  While enhancing and preserving, we also must celebrate individualism within that framework.

From a consumer point of view, there had better be something to attract the next purchaser for their business, home or property; the next “investor.”  While recent years has seen a decline in the investor mentality as a primary motivator for choosing real estate purchases, the change model holds true.  It is the value proposition that has changed.  People are looking for authentic lifestyle and an atmosphere that helps them become a contributing part of the community.

The mindset of a destination community being simply a marketable amenity delivery system has to change if a community is to thrive. In funding new development, the purchase and flip investor mentality made pre-construction sales to investors a reliable funding option until about 2008.  This has changed particularly if a destination wants to attract in migration in the second home and retirement markets.  We are now focused on an end user, a citizen, which is much more concerned with the authentic community values than the marketability of the real estate in the future.

Community must be defined as collection of human relationships rather than as a defined real estate space.  Many of the early pioneer destination communities were built with these more humanistic goals in mind.  In the 90’s and 00’s, many designs strayed for these values.  Creating fortified islands of monoculture did much harm to the traditional meaning of community.  The truly extraordinary places designed the governance structure to add value and enhance the region’s authentic nature.  This goes beyond the physical design of the neighborhoods.  There are many extraordinary places that have technical design issues that they continue to deal with as knowledge on neighborhood and civic space design evolves.  These places are extraordinary because the citizens are part of the positive regional dynamic rather than a separate protectionist subculture.

Now that some of our early pioneer associations are reaching 30 to 40 years old, we are starting to see some multigenerational ownership beginning.  Up until recently no current owners where born and raised in their community.  It was a created environment based on a theme that was quickly put in place rather than slowly evolving with the nature of the area.  There were no roots to speak of that would build a sense of citizenship as opposed to walking into a readymade ala carte consumer environment.  Mixed generation communities have faired much better over recent years than age restricted or retirement type communities.  Mutigenerational populations tend to vest much more quickly into the total community environment, both within and outside the association scope.  This is beginning to alleviate some of the challenges faced due to a transient consumer mindset that has been prevalent in community associations.

Boomers are not necessarily joiners.  The value of being a “member” is not nearly as prevalent as with prior generations.  There is much more value placed on being an individual engaged citizen.  This does not mean that the Boomer will not use the amenities of a community.  They may very well be more active than prior generations but the do not want any part of their “parents retirement community.”  They want to live in a community that engages their children and grandchildren as a family unit and individuals.  They want a “cool” factor.  There must be a new mental narrative about the community. They envision their grandchildren saying “let’s visit grandpa, he lives in the coolest place”. This is what the successful community of the future will be conjure in the mind.

A primary challenge is developing a real sense of citizenship.  Consumers look at the cost/benefit now and seek to extract as much product as possible for the least cost.  Citizen community builders have a longer look as they take responsibility in growing their community.  The sense of being a builder not simply a consumer is what builds community within our members.